王伟,陈孝政,刘欣春,曹长群,叶法丞,王玥,刘静

• 1:中国科学院南京地质古生物研究所

摘要(Abstract)：

以二叠系碳同位素地层学研究为例,在有条件控制的实验模拟基础上发现:1)采集到的地质样品一般都是不同碳酸盐矿物的混合样品,这些不同碳酸盐矿物具有不同的碳氧同位素比值(δ13C和δ18O);2)自然露头和采石场剖面样品的无机碳氧稳定同位素组成会在可预见的时间内发生足以影响研究结果的淋滤交代作用;3)利用地层中碳酸盐样品的δ13C研究地层划分和对比时,δ13C的数值和变化趋势受到该地层沉积相等因素的限制;4)利用δ13C和δ18O的相关性判断样品的可靠性时受严格的条件限制。为解决碳同位素地层学研究中的这些困难,通过研究和实验模拟及相关应用尝试,有条件地提出了以下解决方案:1)混合样品的单矿物分析方法;2)通过相差逼近法和模拟交代法判断样品的可靠性,并对其原始δ13C值进行逼近并讨论其可能的应用。对碳同位素比值不能简单用于地层划分与对比的观点进行了讨论并提出了初步的解决方案,同时初步限定了碳同位素地层学研究中的应用及推测的条件。

关键词(KeyWords)： 同位素地层学;碳同位素;地层划分与对比;实验模拟;淋滤交代作用;二叠系;中国

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金项目(NSFC);; 中国科学院方向性项目的支持

作者(Author): 王伟,陈孝政,刘欣春,曹长群,叶法丞,王玥,刘静

DOI: 10.19839/j.cnki.dcxzz.2011.03.011

参考文献(References)：

• 曹长群,王伟,金玉.2002.浙江煤山二叠-三叠系界线附近的碳同位素变化.科学通报,47(4):302-306
• 陈锦石,邵茂茸,霍卫国,姚御元.1984.浙江长兴二叠系和三叠系界限地层的碳同位素,地质科学,(1):88-93
• 黄俊华,罗根明,白晓,汤新燕.2007.浙江煤山P/T之交碳同位素对有机碳埋藏的指示意义.地球科学--中国地质大学学报,32(2):767-773
• 黄思静.1994.上扬子二叠系-三叠系初海相碳酸盐岩的碳同位素组成与生物绝灭事件.地球化学,(1):60-68
• 黄思静,Qing Hai-ruo,黄培培,胡作维,王庆东,邹明亮,刘昊年.2008.晚二叠世-早三叠世海水的锶同位素组成与演化--基于重庆中梁山海相碳酸盐的研究结果.中国科学(D辑),38(3):273-283
• 翦知湣,金海燕.2008.大洋碳循环与气候演变的热带驱动.地球科学进展,23(3):221-227
• 金玉,沈树忠,Henderson C M,王向东,王伟,王玥,曹长群,尚庆华,郑全锋.2007.瓜达鲁普统(Guadalupian)-乐平统(Lopingian)全球界线层型剖面和点(GSSP).地层学杂志,31(1):1-13
• 赖旭龙,孙亚东,江海水.2009.峨眉山大火成岩省火山活动与中/晚二叠世之交生物大灭绝.中国科学基金,(6):353-356
• 李玉成.1998.华南二叠系长兴阶层型剖面碳酸盐岩的碳氧同位素比值地层.地层学杂志,22(1):36-41
• 李玉成,黄宝玉,徐永昌.2001.利用贝类(Lamprotula)化石碳氧同位素再建山西丁村地区晚更新世气候环境.沉积学报,19(4):648-651
• 刘欣春,陈孝政,叶法丞,刘静,王玥,廖卓庭,祁玉平,郑全锋,王伟.2010.川东北二叠系-三叠系界线附近微生物岩微观表面特征观察研究.古生物学报,49(2):261-268
• 南君亚,刘育燕.2004.浙江煤山二叠-三叠系界线剖面有机和无机碳同位素变化与古环境.地球化学,33(1):9-19
• 苏瑞侠,朱照宇,孙东怀.2005.海生贝类壳体生长层的高分辨率同位素记录研究.自然科学进展,15(9):1080-1085
• 汪品先.2006.大洋碳循环的地质演变.自然科学进展,16(11):1361-1370
• 汪品先.2009.穿凿地球系统的时间隧道.中国科学(D辑),39(10):1313-1338
• 汪品先,田军,成鑫荣,刘传联,徐建.2003.探索大洋碳储库的演变周期.科学通报,48(21):2216-2227
• 王伟,朱自立,沈树忠.1997.西藏色龙二叠系-三叠系界线剖面的碳同位素特征及意义.科学通报,42(4):406-408
• 闫慧,李心清,周会.2008.淡水双壳类壳体碳同位素研究:以河蚬(Corbicula flumineaMiiller,1774)为例.地球化学,(3):275-280
• 严正,徐道一,叶莲芳,刘荣谟.1991.浙江长兴煤山二叠-三叠系界线剖面的碳同位素异常.Palaeoworld,1:113-119
• 殷鸿福,谢树成,秦建中,颜佳新,罗根明.2008.对地球生物学,生物地质学和地球生物相的一些探讨.中国科学(D辑),38(12):1473-1480
• 郑永飞,徐宝龙,周根陶.2000.矿物稳定同位素地球化学研究.地学前缘,7(2):299-320
• 左景勋,童金南,邱海鸥,赵来时.2006.下扬子地区早三叠世碳酸盐岩碳同位素组成的演化特征.中国科学(D辑),36(2):109-122
• Arthur M A.1984.Carbon isotope anomalies Nature,310:450-451
• Arthur M A,Dean WE&Claypool G E.1985.Anomalous13Cen-richment in modern marine organic carbon.Nature,315:216-218
• Baud A,Magaritz M&Holser WT.1989.Permian-Triassic of theTethys:carbon isotope studies.Geologische Rundschau,78(2):649-677
• Bond D P G,Wignall P B,Wang Wei&Izon G.2010.The mid-Capitanian(Middle Permian)mass extinction and carbon iso-tope record of South China.Palaeogeography,Palaeoclima-tology,Palaeoecology,292(1-2):282-294
• Bowring S A,Erwin D H,Jin Yu-gan,Martin M W,Davidek K&Wang Wei.1998.U/Pb zircon geochronology and tempo of theend-Permian mass extinction.Science,280:1039-1045
• Brand U&Veizer J.1980.Chemical diagenesis of a multicomponentcarbonate system-1:trace elements.Journal of SedimentaryPetrology,50(4):1219-1236
• Brand U&Veizer J.1981.Chemical diagenesis of a multicomponentcarbonate system-2:stable isotopes.Journal of SedimentaryResearch,51(3):987-997
• Brasier M D,Magaritz M M,Corfield R,Luo HL,Wu X C,Ouy-ang L,Jiang Z W,Hamdi B,He T G&Fraser A G.1990.The carbon-and oxygen-isotope record of the Precambrian-Cambrian boundary interval in China and Iran and their correla-tion.Geological Magazine,127(4):319-332
• Brasier M D&Anderson M M.1992.Oxygen and carbon isotopestratigraphy of Early Cambrian carbonatesin southeastern New-foundland and England.Geological Magazine,129(3):265-279
• Cao Chang-qun,Love G D,Hays L E,Wang Wei,Shen Shu-zhong&Summons R E.2009.Biogeochemical evidence for euxinic o-ceans and ecological disturbance presaging the end-Permianmass extinction event.Earth and Planetary Science Letters,281(3-4):188-201
• Cao Chang-qun,Wang Wei&Jin Yu-gan.2002.Carbonisotope ex-cursions across the Permian-Triassic boundary in the Meishansection,Zhejiang Province,China.Chinese Science Bulletin,47(13):1125-1129
• Cao Chang-qun,Wang Wei,Liu Lu-jun,Shen Shu-zhong&Sum-mons R E.2008.Two episodes of13C-depletionin organic car-bon in the latest Permian:evidence from the terrestrial se-quences in northern Xinjiang,China.Earthand Planetary Sci-ence Letters,270(3-4):251-257
• Cao Chang-qun,Yang Y C,Shen Shu-zhong,Wang Wei,ZhengQuan-feng&Summons R E.2010.Pattern of13Ccarbandimpli-cations for geological events during the Permian-Triassic transi-tionin South China.Geological Journal,45(2-3):186-194
• Chaudhuri P&Marron J S.1999.Sizer for exploration of structurein curves,Journal ofthe American Statistical Association,94:807-823
• Curtis C D,Coleman ML&Love L G.1986.Pore water evolutionduring sediment burial fromisotopic and mineral chemistry ofcalcite,dolomite and siderite concretions.Geochimicaet Cosmo-chimica Acta,50(10):2321-2334
• Dodd J R&Stanton RJ.1990.Paleoecology,concepts and applica-tions.John Wilev&Sons,ISBN0-471-85711-4,1-502
• Fairchild I J&Marshall J D.1990.Stratigraphic shifts in carboni-sotopes fromProterozoic stromatolitic carbonates(Mauritania):influences of primary mineralogy and diagenesis.AmericanJournal of Science,290(A):46-79
• Friedli H,L tscher H,Oeschger H,Siegenthaler Uet al.1986.Icecore record of the13C/12C ratio of at mospheric CO2in the pasttwo centuries.Nature,324:237-238
• Galindo C,Casquet C,Rapela C,Pankhurst RJ,Baldo E&Saave-dra J.2004.Sr,C,and Oisotope geochemistry and stratigra-phy of Precambrian and Lower Paleozoic carbonate sequencesfromthe Western Sierras Pampeanas of Argentina:tectonic im-plications.Precambrian Research,131(1-2):55-71
• Grossman E L,Mii H S&Yancey T E.1993.Stable isotopes inLate Pennsylvanian brachiopods fromthe United States:impli-cations for Carboniferous paleoceanography.GSABulletin,105(10):1284-129
• Grossman E L,Yancey T E&Jones T E.2008.Glaciation,aridifi-cation,and carbon sequestration in the Permo-Carboniferous:the isotopic record from low latitudes.Palaeogeography,Palaeoclimatology,Palaeoecology,268(3-4):222-233
• Heydari E,Wade WJ&Hassanzadehc J.2001.Diagenetic origin ofcarbon and oxygen isotope compositions of Permian-Triassicboundary strata,Sedimentary Geology,143(3-4):191-197
• Hips K&Haas J.2009.Facies and diagenetic evaluation of the Per-mian-Triassic boundary interval and basal Triassic carbonates:shallowand deep ramp sections,Hungary.Facies,55:421-442
• Holser WT,Sch nlaub HP,Attrep AJ,Boeckel mann K,Klein Pet al.1989.Aunique geochemical record at the Permian/Trias-sic boundary.Nature,337:39-44
• Holser WT,Sch nlaub HP,Boeckel mann K&Magaritz M.1991.The Permian-Triassic of the Gartnerkofel-1Core(Carnic Alps,Austria):synthesis and conclusions.Abh Geol B A,45:213-232
• Jin Yu-gan,Shen Shu-zhong,Henderson C M,Wang Xiang-dong,Wang Wei,Wang Yue,Cao Chang-qun&Shang Qing-hua.2006.The Global Stratotype Section and Point(GSSP)for thebase-Wuchiapingian Stage and base-Lopingian(Upper Permian)Series.Episodes,29(4):253-262
• Jin Yu-gan,Wang Yue,Henderson C M,Shen Shu-zhong,CaoChang-qun&Wang Wei.2006.The Global Stratotype Sectionand Point(GSSP)for the base-Changhsingian Stage(UpperPermian).Episodes,29(3):175-182
• Jin Yu-gan,Wang Yue,Wang Wei,Shang Qin-hua,Cao Chang-qun&Erwin D H.2000.Pattern of marine mass extinction nearthe Permian-Triassic boundary in South China,Science,289(5478):432-436
• Kano A,Kakizaki Y,Takashima C,Wang Wei&Matsumoto R.2007.Facies and depositional environment of the uppermost Ju-rassic stromatoporoid biostromesinthe Zagros Mountin of Iran.GFF,129:107-122
• Kearsey T,Twitchett RJ,Price G D&Grimes S T.2009.Isotopeexcursions and palaeotemperature estimates fromthe Permian/Triassic boundaryin the Southern Alps(Italy).Palaeogeogra-phy,Palaeoclimatology,Palaeoecology,279(1-2):29-40
• Killingley J S&Berger W H.1979.Stable isotopes in a molluskshell:detection of upwelling events.Science,20(4402):186-188
• Kroopnick P M.1985.The distribution ofC ofΣCO2in the worldoceans.Deep sea research Part A.Oceanographic Research Pa-pers,32(1):57-84
• Kump L R.1991,Interpreting carbon-isotope excursions:strange-love oceans.Geology,19(4):299-302
• Lai Xu-long,Wang Wei,Wignall P B,Bond D P G,Jiang HS,AliJ R,John E H&Sun Y D.2008.Palaeoenvironmental changeduring the end-Guadalupian(Permian)mass extinction in Si-chuan,China.Palaeogeography,Palaeoclimatology,Palaeo-ecology,269(1-2):78-93
• Levin I.1987.At mospheric CO2in continental European alternativeapproach to clean air CO2data.Tellus B,39(B):21-28
• Magaritz M M.1983.Carbon and oxygenisotope composition of re-cent and ancient coated grains.In:Peryt T M ed.Coatedgrains.Berlin:Springer-Verlag.27-37
• Magaritz M,Bart R,Baud A&Holser WT.1988.The carbon-iso-tope shift at the Permian/Triassic boundary in the southernAlps is gradual.Nature,331:337-339
• Magaritz M.1989.13C minima follow extinction events:a clue tofaunal radiation.Geology,17(4):337-340
• Matsumoto R.1990.Vuggy carbonate crust formed by hydrocarbonseepage onthe continental shelf of BaffinIsland,northeast Can-ada Vuggy carbonate crust formed by hydrocarbon seepage onthe continental shelf of Baffin Island,Northeast Canada.Geo-chemJ,24:143-158
• Mii H,Grossman E L&Yancey T E.1997.Stable carbon and oxy-genisotope shifts in Permian seas of West Spitsbergen:globalchange or diagenetic artifact Geology,25(3):227-230
• Mook WG.1986.13Cin at mospheric CO2.Netherlands Journal ofSea Research,20(2-3):211-223
• Mu Xi-nan,Kershaw S,Li Yue,Guo L,Qi Yet al.2009.High-resolution carbon isotope changes in the Permian-Triassicboundary interval,Chongqing,South China:implications forcontrol and growth of earliest Triassic microbialites.Journal ofAsian Earth Sciences,36(6):434-441
• Powell M D&Kyser T K.1991.Analysis ofδ13Candδ18Oin cal-cite,dolomite,rhodochrosite and siderite using a laser extrac-tion system.Chemical Geology,94:55-66
• Quay P,Sonnerup R,Westby T,Stutsman J&McNichol A.2003.Changes in the13C/12C of dissolved inorganic carbon in the o-cean as a tracer of anthropogenic CO2uptake.Global Biogeo-chem Cycles,17:1004,doi:10.1029/2001GB001817
• Rohling EJ&Palike H.2005.Centennial-scale climate cooling witha sudden cold event around8,200years ago.Nature,434(7036):975-979
• Rounick J S&Winterbourn MJ.1986.Stable carbon isotopes andcarbon flowin ecosystems.BioScience,36(3):171-177
• Shen Shu-zhong,Cao Chang-qun,Henderson C M,Wang Xiang-dong,Shi G R,Wang Wei&Wang Yue.2006.End-Permianmass extinction patternin the northern peri-Gondwanan region.Palaeoworld,1(1):3-30
• Shen Shu-zhong&Shi G R.2009.Latest Guadalupian brachiopodsfromthe Guadalupian/Lopingian boundary GSSPsection at Pen-glaitanin Laibin,Guangxi,South China andimplications for thetiming of the pre-Lopingian crisis.Palaeoworld,18(2-3):152-161
• Shen Shu-zhong,Wang Yue,Henderson C M,Cao Chang-qun&Wang Wei.2007Biostratigraphy and lithofacies of the PermianSystemin the Laibin-Heshan area of Guangxi,South China.Palaeoworld,16(1-3):120-139
• Swart P K.2008.Global synchronous changesinthe carbonisotopiccomposition of carbonate sediments unrelated to changes in theglobal carbon cycle.PNAS,105(37):13741-13745
• Swart P K&Eberli G.2005.The nature of theδ13C of periplat-form sediments:implications for stratigraphy and the globalcarbon cycle.Sedimentary Geology,175:115-129
• Tappan H.1968.Primary production,isotopes,extinctions and theat mosphere.Palaeogeography,Palaeoclimatology,Palaeo-ecology,4(3):187-210
• Veizer J,Ala D,Azmy K,Bruckschen P,Buhl D,Bruhn F,CardenG A F,Diener A,Ebneth Set al.1999.87Sr/86Sr,δ13C andδ18O evolution of Phanerozoic seawater.Chemical Geology,161(1-3):59-88
• Wang Kun,Geldsetzer H HJ&Krouse HR.1994.Permian-Trias-sic extinction:organicδ13C evidence from British Columbia,Canada.Geology,22(7):580-584
• Wang Wei,Cao Chang-qun&Wang Yue.2004.The carbonisotopeexcursion on GSSP candidate section of Lopingian-Guadalupianboundary.Earth and Planetary Science Letters,220:57-67
• Wang Wei,Kano A,Okumura T,Ma Y,Matsumoto R,MatsudaN,Ueno K,Chen X Z,Kakuwa Y,Gharaie M H M&IlkhchiM R.2007.Isotopic chemostratigraphy of the microbialite-bearing Permian-Triassic boundary section in the ZagrosMountains,Iran.Chemical Geology,244(3-4):708-714
• Wang Wei&Matsumoto R.2005.Isotopic chemostratigraphy ofthe Permian-Triassic boundary in Zagros Mountains,Aligou-darz,Iran.Permophiles,45:31-36
• Wignall P B,Vedrine S,Bond D P G,Wang Wei,Lai Xu-long,AliJ R&Jiang HS.2009.Facies analysis and sea-level change atthe Guadalupian-Lopingian Global Stratotype(Laibin,SouthChina),and its bearing on the end-Guadalupian mass extinc-tion.Journal ofthe Geological Society,166(4):655-666
• Xu Dao-yi&Yan Zheng.1993.Carbon isotope and iridium eventmarkers near the Permian/Triassic boundary in the Meishansection,Zhejiang Province,China.Palaeogeography,Palaeo-climatology,Palaeoecology,104(1-4):171-176
• Yin Hong-fu,Wu Shu-bao,Ding Ming-hua,Zhang Ke-xin&TongJin-nan.1994.The Meishan section candidate of the globalstratotype section and point(GSSP)of the Permian-Triassicboundary(PTB).Albertiana,14(11):15-31